RestaurantsHighlandEdinbaneIV51

Harden's says

The lodge (built in 1543) has a restaurant with four luxury rooms; food comes from native Skye chef Calum Montgomery.

survey result

Summary

£160
£££££
5
Exceptional
4
Very Good
4
Very Good
* Based on a three course dinner, half a bottle of wine, coffee, cover charge, service and VAT.

“Bravo!”. “Dinner is nothing short of magical” for fans – ie all who report – on this 16th-century hunting lodge, converted by chef-patron Calum Montgomery in 2018 and “well-deserving of its four AA rosette status” (it was the first establishment in the Highlands to achieve this, in 2022). “The welcome is warm and genuine and the young team exude professionalism and charm that belie their years”. “Chef Calum serves dishes that are technically skilled, using the most incredible of ingredients fresh from the sea and land that are utterly delicious”. “What stands out is the incredible attention to detail, with each dish so detailed, and so delicately prepared… almost like a love letter to the Isle of Skye, showcasing locally grown ingredients with immense creativity, skill and care. By the end of the meal, we weren’t just satisfied, we actually felt quite inspired”. Top Menu Tip – “the largest scallop I’ve ever seen on a plate. The amazing sweet and fresh flavour was perhaps explained by the fact that it had been caught in the nearby Lochbay two hours before it landed at our table!”

Summary

£157
£££££
5
Exceptional
4
Very Good
4
Very Good
* Based on a three course dinner, half a bottle of wine, coffee, cover charge, service and VAT.

“Showcasing the wonderful Hebridean produce of the Isle of Skye with a superb taster menu” – chef-patron Calum Montgomery converted this 16th-century hunting lodge in 2018 into “the most wonderful restaurant with rooms” and it is nowadays second-to-none on the island in terms of the feedback we receive. “That they source all of their ingredients from the region is pleasing to see, and you can tell how much passion goes into the preparation”: “The fish and seafood is so fresh and so delicious… it could be caught that morning and on your plate that evening: epic”. One puzzle – “it deserves a star!” from the tyre men.

Summary

£66
  £££
5
Exceptional
4
Very Good
4
Very Good
* Based on a three course dinner, half a bottle of wine, coffee, cover charge, service and VAT.

“The tasting menu is a real journey around Skye, sampling the best of local produce” at Calum Montgomery’s converted hunting lodge (built in 1543, revamped in 2018) – the ten-course meal is £125 per person. The result is “some of the most exciting cooking you will find, with THE freshest and most local Scottish produce”. But while all reports here say results are “unbeatable”, they still haven’t been blessed with a star by the tyre manufacturers based in Clermont-Ferrand… just a matter of time surely?

Summary

£66
  £££
5
Exceptional
4
Very Good
4
Very Good
* Based on a three course dinner, half a bottle of wine, coffee, cover charge, service and VAT.

“Really outstanding… and so surprising to find in such a location” – Calum Montgomery’s converted hunting lodge (built in 1543 and extensively refurbed in 2018) is “so much better than so many acclaimed restaurants” (and invites comparisons with the much more established nearby Three Chimneys, which it narrowly edges with its food rating). The focus is on his ‘Taste of Skye’ ten-course tasting menu showcasing local produce and delivered by “friendly and attentive” staff. Ratings this year and last suggest it’s “worthy of a Michelin star” but no sign yet: “maybe they’re too modest”. Perhaps the Tyre Men will finally catch on in their 2023 awards as in late 2022 the AA promoted him from 3 to 4 rosettes.

For 35 years we've been curating reviews of the UK's most notable restaurant. In a typical year, diners submit over 50,000 reviews to create the most authoritative restaurant guide in the UK. Each year, the guide is re-written from scratch based on this survey (although for the 2021 edition, reviews are little changed from 2020 as no survey could run for that year).

Have you eaten at Edinbane Lodge?

Old Dunvegan Road, Edinbane, IV51 9PW

Restaurant details

No dress code

Edinbane Lodge Restaurant Diner Reviews

Reviews of Edinbane Lodge Restaurant in IV51, Edinbane by users of Hardens.com. Also see the editors review of Edinbane Lodge restaurant.
Hannah D
Edinbane Lodge was undoubtedly the standout...
Reviewed 1 months, 25 days ago

"Edinbane Lodge was undoubtedly the standout meal during our trip around the highlands of Scotland. We were greeted with a genuinely warm welcome and invited to enjoy a drink in the bar before dinner. I opted for their 'Elderberry Negroni' and my husband had a 'New Old Fashioned'. Both were excellent and really set the tone for what was a great evening ahead. After being seated for dinner, we received some incredibly moreish crackers and dip almost immediately which was great as we had been anticipating and saving ourselves for this meal all day. We both had the wine pairing which was thoughtfully curated and complemented each course beautifully. The dry furmint from Hungary was a particular favourite of mine. The sommelier was excellent too, very personable, knowledgeable and engaging. Course after course, we were blown away. Hyper-local produce cooked to perfection with excellent accompaniments and beautifully presented. To highlight just how low the food-mileage really is there was a 'Provenance' card which accompanied the menu at every table. A huge percentage of our meal had actually grown within the grounds of Edinbane Lodge itself either foraged, or planted and grown within their polytunnel. Chef Calum came out to present the oyster dish, finishing it table-side which was such a lovely touch. He was so friendly, it was almost as though we had been welcomed into his home! Chef Calum even wished us a happy anniversary which made us feel extra special. The dish that he brought out was incredible - a beautiful handcrafted bowl from their neighbours at Edinbane Pottery was placed in front of us with a cheese custard and foraged mushrooms that the chefs had collected earlier that week. Chef Calum topped it with a beef consommé made from local beef bones, split it with a chive oil made from home-grown chives and then topped it with an oyster which he had barbequed in aged beef fat... Wow. And that feeling only continued as the night went on. Just as we thought that the meal couldn't get any better, the dessert 'Falasgair' was brought out. This is unlike any dessert I have ever had before and probably ever will have again. Based on the Skye/Highland tradition of heather burning which we are told is one of Chef Calum's favourite scents, the dessert consists of burnt heather ice-cream, heather honey and whisky jelly, almond sponge and praline, and a smoked caramel, finished at the table with a few 'spritzes' of Torabhaig whisky. From the presentation to the storytelling and of course the unique flavour itself, this is a dish we will be talking about for years to come. I think what stood out the most was the team themselves. Every member of staff was incredibly friendly whilst still maintaining a level of professionalism one would expect in an establishment such as this. But there was a genuine sense of enjoyment and enthusiasm among the team that felt completely natural rather than rehearsed. The atmosphere was incredible, and it made the experience truly memorable. Every accolade they have already achieved is clearly well deserved and we found ourselves wondering when, rather than if, a Michelin Star will follow. The entire experience was exceptional - rivalling, and in many cases exceeding that of Michelin-starred restaurants we have dined in previously."

Report this comment
Have you eaten at Edinbane Lodge?
Post your own review of Edinbane Lodge and contribute to our annual restaurant review guide.
Post your own review

Prices

Availability 2 courses 3 courses coffee included service included
Dinner   £105.00
  Cost Availability Courses
Menu1 150.00 Dinner only 7
Drinks  
Wine per bottle £50.00
Filter Coffee £5.00
Extras  
Bread £7.00
Service 13.00%
Old Dunvegan Road, Edinbane, IV51 9PW
Opening hours
Monday5:30 pm‑8:45 pm
Tuesday5:30 pm‑8:45 pm
Wednesday5:30 pm‑8:45 pm
Thursday5:30 pm‑8:45 pm
Friday5:30 pm‑8:45 pm
SaturdayCLOSED
SundayCLOSED

Best Scottish restaurants nearby

The Three Chimneys
Scottish restaurant in Dunvegan
£156
£££££
4
Very Good
4
Very Good
4
Very Good
Scorrybreac
Scottish restaurant in Portree
£107
£££££
4
Very Good
4
Very Good
3
Good
Kinloch Lodge
Scottish restaurant in Sleat
£141
£££££
3
Good
3
Good
4
Very Good