RestaurantsLondonN1C

Harden's says

At Mare Street Market in the King's Cross regeneration zone, a modern take on 'surf and turf' created by two highly regarded chefs. Tom Brown of Pearly Queen and formerly Cornerstone looks after the fish and seafood, which Brad Carter of the late, lamented Carter's of Moseley in Birmingham is in charge of the steakhouse portion of the menu.

survey result

Summary

Occupying a huge, new unit in Mare Street Market – part of the northward creep of the King’s Cross regeneration zone – this modern take on ‘surf ’n’ turf’ opened in July 2025, complete with lots of chandeliers (and a rather dubious carpet). The menu is overseen by two starry chefs: Tom Brown of Pearly Queen and the Capital Hotel looks after the fish and seafood, which Brad Carter of the late, lamented Carter’s of Moseley in Birmingham is in charge of the steakhouse portion of the menu.

For 34 years we've been curating reviews of the UK's most notable restaurant. In a typical year, diners submit over 50,000 reviews to create the most authoritative restaurant guide in the UK. Each year, the guide is re-written from scratch based on this survey (although for the 2021 edition, reviews are little changed from 2020 as no survey could run for that year).

Have you eaten at Island?

Lewis Cubitt Square, London, N1C 4DY

What the Newspaper Critics are saying

The Times

Jay Rayner sampled this collaboration between “seafood maven” Tom Brown (ex-Cornerstone and Pearly Queen) and the “carnivorous” Brad Carter (ex-Carters of Moseley), who “stick resolutely to the idea that surf and turf don’t merely have to cohabit; they can mount each other rigorously.”

Hence dishes like squid stuffed with sobrasada salami; kofta of duck minced with mussels; and beef flank mashed with whitebait and deep-fried – “brash” flavours on a menu that is “the edible equivalent of a Roy Lichtenstein canvas. It’s all ‘Wham!’, ‘Blam!’ and ‘Pop!’.”

If these “flavour bombs can become relentless”, Jay conceded, the venue is aimed firmly at a younger crowd and is “all huge fun and also completely bonkers” – while he also ventured to suggest that “a little inebriation” might help one’s enjoyment of the experience.

Jay Rayner - 2025-09-28
Lewis Cubitt Square, London, N1C 4DY

Best Fish & seafood restaurants nearby

Barrafina
Spanish restaurant in King’s Cross
£70
  £££
4
Very Good
4
Very Good
3
Good
North Sea Fish
Fish & chips restaurant in Bloomsbury
£53
   ££
4
Very Good
3
Good
2
Average
Prawn on the Lawn
Fish & seafood restaurant in Islington
£84
 ££££
4
Very Good
2
Average
2
Average