RestaurantsFifeSt AndrewsKY16

survey result

Summary

“On the top floor of this hotel which overlooks the 18th on The Old Course and then on to the magnificent West Sands where the opening to ‘Chariots of Fire’ was filmed, there are few more romantic places in Scotland” (well, so long as your partner doesn’t hate golf!) than the wood-panelled rooftop dining room of this upscale four-star hotel. Our feedback (admittedly limited) says “do try the traditional Sunday lunch” and Afternoon tea here is also a feature. When it comes to the more substantial fare – majoring in a selection of Aberdeen Angus steaks – we have less feedback, although in his September 2024 review, The Observer’s Jay Rayner was put off by what he saw as a craving for “an awful lot of grilled cow” (noting as he fled an atmosphere that “smells of newly pumped testosterone”).

For 34 years we've been curating reviews of the UK's most notable restaurant. In a typical year, diners submit over 50,000 reviews to create the most authoritative restaurant guide in the UK. Each year, the guide is re-written from scratch based on this survey (although for the 2021 edition, reviews are little changed from 2020 as no survey could run for that year).

Have you eaten at 18 at the Russacks St Andrews Hotel?

Pilmour Links, St Andrews, KY16 9JQ

What the Newspaper Critics are saying

The Observer

Jay Rayner suffered for his art at a restaurant in a “fancy hotel” overlooking the 18th hole of the Old Course, a place of pilgrimage for golfers. This meant the place was heaving with “a certain kind of middle-aged man, most of them American… not just seated at the tables but thronging between them and leaning over the shoulders of friends at other tables to bark with laughter at each other’s jokes and war stories”.

The restaurant has hired Billy Boyter, previously chef-patron at the Cellar in nearby Anstruther, presumably to do “ornate and detailed things with the best ingredients”. All to little avail: “The core clientele didn’t get the memo. What this lot want – and what they get – is cow. An awful lot of grilled cow.”

While Jay didn’t mention him, it was difficult not to think of a certain large, orange US presidential candidate when reading his review. “Rarely have I punched the lift button down to ground with such a profound eagerness and glee”, he noted, as he fled the “smells of newly pumped testosterone”. 

Jay rayner - 2024-09-29
Pilmour Links, St Andrews, KY16 9JQ
Opening hours
Monday6 pm‑12 am
Tuesday6 pm‑12 am
Wednesday12:30 pm‑3 pm, 6 pm‑12 am
Thursday12:30 pm‑3 pm, 6 pm‑12 am
Friday12:30 pm‑3 pm, 6 pm‑12 am
Saturday12:30 pm‑3 pm, 6 pm‑12 am
Sunday12 pm‑3 pm, 6 pm‑12 am

Best restaurants nearby

Haar
Scottish restaurant in St Andrews
£143
£££££
4
Very Good
3
Good
3
Good
PizzaExpress
Pizza restaurant in St Andrews
£58
   ££
2
Average
3
Good
3
Good
The Shoregate
Scottish restaurant in Crail
£56
   ££
3
Good
2
Average
4
Very Good